Hey guys, thanks for all the responses, I really appreciate it!
I did take a look at the FZ8, and it seems like a fine bike as well. But as some people already mentioned, on this bike I'm looking for *reasonable* power. My big problem with the supersports, especially the 1000, is that most of the time I'm entirely within the bottom third of the tach, because going higher than that is frankly just unsafe and/or illegal on actual road circumstances. I suspect it might be fun to have a bike where I can really twist the throttle when I want to get up and go, rather than having to baby it all the time. But it's definitely a valid point that there might be some system shock in going to a less powerful class of bike. I wish I could test ride one; I'll have to see what I can work out.
I definitely like the fairing, as I've never been a fan of the half-faired look. It just looks like they forgot to bolt the fairing back on. Should looks be a determining factor? Probably not, but I can't help it! The looks, along with the price point and the good mileage are all pretty compelling. Going
I think at this point I'm probably just coming up with excuses to justify a decision that I've already made
More questions: Is freeway riding fairly comfortable on this bike (i.e. not an excessive amount of vibration), as well as pair riding? I don't do much of either, but I don't want to find myself in a situation where either of those is uncomfortable. I'd definitely like to take some road trips, although those will probably be solo. I'm 6'3" ~215lb, for whatever that would factor in.
EDIT: I noticed that BKP commented on this already, thanks!